Latest News

Will Khusboo have the last laugh?

By Srinivas Bodduluri

kushboo

kushboo

A girl called Khusboo Khan stepped out of VIII Class to try her luck in the tinsel town of Mumbai. Having everything in excess, she was promptly passed on and South India Cinema, reconciled to live largely on English and Hindi film left-overs, greedily lollipopped her up. With a 100 roles in her kitty, she moved on to the idiot box. Khusboo grew too big to be confined to calendars in bars and wine shops and so became a statue in a temple in Tiruchirapalli, transcending one place of temporary inebriation to another of permanent inebriation.

Now, Khusboo took her role seriously and so had to deliver sermons too. Success justifies the means adopted and Khusboo honestly believed that what was good for her was good for the rest of us too, more particularly the fairer sex of Tamil Nadu. So, she chastised society for twining marriage with sex and exhorted that sex need not wait till marriage. She admonished all suitable boys to desist from insisting on virginity of grooms. ‘India Today’, which continually dolls out titillating soft-porn like pulp journalism in the name of surveys about life styles, to keep its circulation swelling, promptly carried the sermon in its English and Tamil editions.

The permissive were shocked that their secrets were made public. The rest were genuinely offended. There was a hue and cry. Khusboo believed her base to be too strong to be shaken. And when a reporter of ‘Dhina Thanti’ sought her clarification, she scorned at the hypocrisy of the rabble rousers, who she said were all indulging in pre-marital sex. Public anger knew no bounds and they slapped 24 criminal cases against her across the length and breadth of Tamil Nadu and one in Indore and roused the Temple to the ground.

The allegations against her were that she defamed woman folk, enraged their modesty etc. Obviously, finding it difficult to carry herself to so many police stations and courts, Khusboo carried the matters to the High Court of Madras. She asked the Court to quash the complaints, exercising its powers under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code, which means stopping the investigation by the police and her prosecution by the lower courts, permanently. This was a power to be exercised sparingly in rare cases where the complaint filed against one is glaringly false or vitiated by some fatal technical defect like being barred by the law of limitation, meaning stale.

Khusboo pleaded that the ‘India Today’ comments were protected by her right to freedom of speech and expression guaranteed by the Constitution of India and those in ‘Dhina Thanti’ were not uttered at all. She seems to have issued a legal notice denying the comments.

Mr. Justice Regupathi frowned upon her arguments. He delivered a judgment on 30-04-2008 called “S.Khusboo versus Kanniammal”, reported in (2008) 2 MLJ 1358 (Mad), dismissing her petitions. The Judge found that ‘India Today’ carried the words of Khusboo saying that “in Indian Society, stuffed with conservative taboos, woman is gradually flapping her wings; that the society should get liberated from the thinking that women should not lose their virginity till marriage and that educated persons should not expect their life partners to be with virginity at the time of marriage”. He noted that she further stated that “if a girl is very serious about her relationship with her opposite sex, the parents should allow such relationship and that, while indulging in premarital sex, care should be taken to avoid pregnancy and venereal diseases.”

He also observed that “when a clarification was sought by a reporter of ‘Dhina Thanti’ that her statements would lead to cultural degradation, Khusboo questioned as to which culture they are referring to and asked as to how many men and women are there in Tamil Nadu who did not indulge in pre-marital sex”.

The Judge then laid down the law that, the defence taken by Khusboo that she was voicing her opinion believing it to be true and bona fide, which was an exception for defamation, related to facts that can only be verified through trial by the lower court and the High Court cannot quash the complaints on such grounds. Khusboo’s respite was limited to the Courts order that all the cases pending in various places would be clubbed together and tried by the Court of the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai.

The judgment of the High Court of Madras is a nice piece of legal literature except the fairly long digression in Paragraph 13, where the actress’s comments on pre-marital sex were given an extended treatment bringing in the concept of heterosexual co-habitation of couples outside marriage. It was unwarranted, having no nexus with the question whether the complaints could be quashed or not. More so, when her comments were not about the phenomenon of live-in partners but were about pre-marital sex. There is thus a mix up that could have been avoided.

Finally, Khusboo’s case landed in the Supreme Court of India and culminated in the juicy comments of the Judges of 23-03-2010, slurped up by the Media and recreated in various forms of sensual sensationalism to almost mean that the Judges had endorsed her views.

Fortunately for Khusboo, our Legal Reporters, as learned as her, if not less, do not know the distinction among comments made by judges while adjudicating the matter, reserving of the judgment and delivering the judgment in open Court. Except a few, all the news reports not only created an impression that the Supreme Court has already confirmed that there is no offence committed by Khusboo but went further to say that the Supreme Court has laid down the law through a verdict that co-habitation without marriage of persons of opposite sex and pre-marital sex were not illegal.

In this sardonic episode, were the Courts ever called upon to decide whether co-habitation of persons of opposite sex and pre-marital sex were legal or illegal? Not at all! Those were not the questions before the Court. Did the Supreme Court deliver any judgement in Khusboo’s case? No! It only heard the matter and reserved the judgment to be delivered later on. Does pre-marital sex attributed by Khusboo to the populace of Tamil Nadu have anything to do with the phenomenon of non-marital co-habitation of opposite sexes? No! Then how on earth did these false reports creep into the media and flashed the world over?

It’s because the Supreme Court of India provided the fodder for the indiscriminately news hungry media. It’s because adjudicatory procedures even in the highest court of the land are wanting in decorum. Because our Judges, only supposed to hear dispassionately, discuss with the counsel or pose questions strictly confining to the subject matters and then deliver the judgment also exhibit a penchant for talking and airing their views on even borderline issues. In umpteen instances the comments of the Courts extricated from the context are given publicity. Ultimately, the comments which are momentary flashes of emotion do not become part of the well considered decisions at all!

Did the presence of parties cause the ease? If the report of the Press Trust of India is to be believed, with goggles pushed over her forehead, Khusboo was relaxing in the front row of the Supreme Court of India, hitherto reserved only for Lawyers arguing cases, while the Judges waxed over her espousal of pre-marital permissiveness drawing parallels with the mythical Radha and Krishna and the media carried the words, the next day. Now it is to be seen what the judgment of the Supreme Court of India is going to be.

Will Khusboo have the last laugh!

Articles

Varavara Rao’s “Captive Imagination” : A sweet retribution in poetry-prose

Varavara Rao's

By Srini Bodduluri The State is capable enough to gobble up the bodies of those it kills, without traces. Yet, it throws up the beaten-to-death and bullet-ridden body of Sakhamuri Appa Rao, the Maoist, for all of us to see. Why? Is it not to instill terror in us so as never to have anything ... ...

General News

AP High Court quashes Muslim Quota

AP High Court quashes Muslim Quota

Hyderabad, Feb. 8 : Resolving the suspense over the much-awaited judgement on the controversial Muslim reservations, the seven-member bench of Andhra Pradesh High Court on Monday quashed the Bill providing four per cent reservations to Muslims in educational institutions created by the Sate Government. The bench headed by Chief Justice Anil Ramesh ...

General News

Bharti Airtel Q3 Net Profit 2,236 cr, average monthly revenue per user 230 rupees

Bharti Airtel Q3 Net Profit 2,236 cr, average monthly revenue per user 230 rupees

MUMBAI: Bharti Airtel Ltd is earning 230 per month on its telephone services users. The company current user base as on December stood at 125 million, which includes Sri Lanka operations. Country’s number one private mobile operator registered 8,755 crore rupees revenue and 2,236 crore rupees net profit for October-December quarter of the 200...

General News

65 DLF Indian Premier League cricket matches live broadcast on You Tube for 45 days

65 DLF Indian Premier League cricket matches live broadcast on You Tube for 45 days

Hyderabad: DLF Indian Premier League cricket matches ( DLF IPL 2010 ) will be broadcast live on social media network You Tube now. Search enginer major Google India announced an agreement with the Indian Premier League and its licensing partner Global Cricket Ventures to live stream all the action from latest season on a dedicated ... ...

General News

Infosys 3rd quarter net profit at Rs 1,582 crore

Hyderabad, January 11: Bangalore headquartered Infosys Technologies Limited today announced financial results for the Quarter Ended December 31, 2009. The  company has registered 2.8% quarter on quarter growth in its income at Rs. 5,741 crore for the quarter. However, on YoY basis income was declined at 0.8%. Net profit stood at 1,582 crore, up 2....

General News

ItzCash Card tops the cash card category in IRCTC Online Booking with 78 per cent

Hyderabad, January 6: Passengers using railways have now preferring to use cash cards for online booking of rail tickets through IRCTC website.  ItzCash card is the only one option to this kind of travelers now an handy option. There has been a surge in cash card transactions at the IRCTC website with around 13 per cent ... ...

General News

Kodak second largest company in Digital cameras sales in India C140 highest selling camera

Hyderabad, January 6: Photography materials maker Kodak has now become a second largest player in Digital cameras category in India replacing Canon, as per the latest IDC report. Kodak is a market leader in retail photo printing, kiosks, films and motion picture films segments. The IDC report pegs Kodak’s market share at 21.6 % in Q3, ... ...

General News

Bharti Airtel warns mobile users on fraudulent callers

Hyderabad, January 05: Bharti Airtel, countries largest private GSM mobile phone network operator warned the public of some fraudulent activity that has potential to impact customers of several mobile operators. The statement said, the customers are arbitrarily being targeted by callers who pretend to be calling on behalf of the customer’s teleco...

General News

Symantec launches three new products focusing mobile devices

 Hyderabad, January 5: Nasdaq listed online security solutions firm Symantec Corp. announced its mobile security and management strategy, including three news products to help organizations secure and manage data on the rising number of mobile devices in the enterprise segment.  Symantec’s mobile strategy focuses on the effective integration of...